Choosing Quality Care
Transparency

Sources and methodology

This guide translates public hospital and nursing home quality and patient safety information into a comparison process for patients, families, and caregivers. The sources below materially informed its content.

How this guide uses information

The guide summarizes and organizes information from public agencies, accrediting organizations, nonprofit reporting programs, specialty societies, and consumer rating services. It does not calculate hospital ratings, independently audit or validate hospital performance, reproduce proprietary methodologies, or recommend or endorse a hospital.

Measures, methods, reporting periods, participation, and website features can change. Visitors should confirm definitions and the latest available results on each original source, record the date or rating edition reviewed, and ask the hospital about missing or conflicting information.

Last source review: September 23, 2026.

Public reporting and accreditation

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services — Medicare Care Compare

Hospital ratings, outcomes, complications, infections, readmissions, patient experience, and other measures.

CMS — Provider Data Catalog: Hospitals

Downloadable hospital quality datasets and measure information.

CMS — Overall Hospital Quality Star Rating

Resources and methodology for the CMS overall hospital rating.

The Leapfrog Group — Hospital Safety Grade

Letter grades and measure details focused on preventable harm.

The Leapfrog Group — Hospital and Surgery Center Ratings

Detailed quality and safety results, including survey measures.

The Joint Commission — Find Accredited Organizations

Accreditation, certification, and verification information.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention — Healthcare-Associated Infection Data

Information about infection measures and national and state progress.

State health departments and licensing agencies

Inspection, complaint, enforcement, adverse-event, maternal health, and infection reporting varies by state. Use the official agency for the state where the hospital is located.

Patient safety and engagement guidance

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality — Engaging Patients and Families

Resources for participating in care and improving safety during a hospital stay.

AHRQ — The 10 Questions You Should Know

Plain-language prompts that encourage patients and families to ask questions and participate in care.

AHRQ — CAHPS Patient Experience Surveys

Standardized patient experience survey information and guidance.

The Joint Commission — Universal Protocol and Right Patient, Right Care

Preprocedure verification, site marking, time-outs, identification, and related safety expectations.

CDC — Standard Precautions for All Patient Care

Hand hygiene, personal protective equipment, and infection-exposure practices.

Specialty care resources

Society of Thoracic Surgeons — Public Reporting

Voluntary public reporting of cardiac, thoracic, and congenital surgical outcomes.

American College of Surgeons — Cancer Programs

Accreditation and quality programs for cancer care.

American Heart Association — Heart Attack Treatment

Patient information used to shape heart-care questions.

American Stroke Association — Choosing Stroke Rehabilitation

Patient and caregiver considerations for stroke services and rehabilitation.

American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons — Joint Replacement Questions

Questions about experience, outcomes, risks, and recovery.

National Cancer Institute — Questions About Cancer Treatment

Questions about treatment choices, side effects, coordination, and clinical trials.

American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists — Levels of Maternal Care

Framework for risk-appropriate maternal services and hospital capabilities.

Additional hospital comparison services

Mayo Clinic — HealthLocator

A hospital comparison view using publicly reported data and specialty results where available.

U.S. News & World Report — Best Hospitals

Annual national, regional, specialty, procedure, and condition ratings.

Healthgrades — Hospital Ratings and Awards Methodology

Methods for hospital outcome ratings and recognition programs.

Castle Connolly

Hospital and physician recognition information. Review the criteria for the specific designation being considered.

Return to the hospital guide

Selected procedure measures and their limits

Public data are not available for every procedure or every facility. The guide maps selected procedures to the CMS measure IDs below, checked against CMS descriptions. This validates the mapping, not a facility’s underlying submissions or an individual patient’s expected outcome. Missing, suppressed, or inapplicable results remain unavailable.

SelectionCMS measuresScope
ColonoscopyOP_32; OP_29Hospital outpatient 7-day unplanned hospital visits; appropriate follow-up screening recommendation where reported. Not all endoscopy.
Hip replacement; knee replacementCOMP_HIP_KNEE; READM_30_HIP_KNEECombined elective hip/knee hospital complication and readmission results, not separate hip-only or knee-only results.
Cataract surgeryOP_31Reported visual-function improvement within 90 days in the hospital outpatient setting. Not all eye surgery or all complications.

Check each measure’s population, units, time period, CMS footnotes, and benchmark comparison. Measures may be restricted to eligible Medicare patients and do not necessarily describe working-age patients, every clinician, or other settings. Hospital-wide stars and inpatient HCAHPS are separate context. Limited comparable measures can produce a gray or yellow summary even when a usable procedure result is displayed.

CMS hospital unplanned visits · CMS hospital complications · CMS timely and effective care · CMS measure definitions and collection periods

Where might more detailed information exist?

Public quality reports cover selected aspects of care—not every diagnosis, treatment, or procedure. A hospital may treat many people with a condition without having publicly reported outcomes specific to that condition.

Hospitals and clinicians may collect additional information through specialty clinical registries—programs that track care and outcomes for particular diseases or procedures. Access varies. Some programs publish selected results for named hospitals or clinical programs. Others primarily provide confidential reports to participating organizations or data to approved researchers.

Choosing Quality Care does not retrieve these registries’ full clinical datasets or include every public reporting source. Where useful public specialty reports are available, this guide may link to them. An unavailable result in this guide does not establish that no relevant information exists elsewhere.

Examples of specialty reporting resources

SpecialtyRegistry or reporting programPublic-access distinction
CancerNational Cancer Database (NCDB)Detailed reports support participating programs; hospital-specific NCDB survival reports are restricted from public release.
CardiologyAmerican College of Cardiology’s NCDR registriesSelected performance information is publicly reported by voluntarily participating hospitals. Full registry data and public reports are different resources.
Heart and chest surgerySociety of Thoracic Surgeons National DatabaseSelected heart, lung, esophageal, and congenital heart surgery outcomes are publicly reported by voluntarily participating programs.
Hip and knee replacementAmerican Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons’ American Joint Replacement Registry (AJRR)Public annual reports provide aggregate findings; detailed institution and surgeon dashboards serve participating organizations and clinicians.
Surgery across specialtiesAmerican College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS NSQIP)Participating organizations receive clinical outcome and benchmarking information. Research files restrict identification of hospitals; they are not an unrestricted public facility-comparison database.
Vascular proceduresSociety for Vascular Surgery Vascular Quality Initiative (SVS VQI)Collects clinical and follow-up outcomes and provides reports for participating centers and regional improvement groups. Public participation information does not provide the same detail as those reports.
Organ transplantationScientific Registry of Transplant Recipients (SRTR)Public program-specific reports include waiting-list and post-transplant outcomes.

Question to ask: “Do you participate in a registry relevant to my treatment, and what results can you share for the specific care I need?”

A missing result does not mean poor care, lack of experience, or an unavailable service. Also distinguish a missing or restricted public result from a temporary retrieval failure; see the report’s retrieval notices.